Published
3 min read
By Tom Whitfield

Retail & Distribution

C-Stores Booked $817.5B in 2025 Sales — Small Negotiations Now Carry Big Stakes

C-stores posted $817.5B in 2025 sales, and consultant John Matthews says terms like freight, rebates and payment windows can beat another point off the invoice.

Negotiation Strategies to Reduce Costs and Strengthen Supplier Relationships
PhotoNegotiation Strategies to Reduce Costs and Strengthen Supplier RelationshipsLuidmilaKot / pixabay

At a glance

  • U.S. convenience stores recorded $817.5 billion in total 2025 sales, including $341.2 billion in-store, per NACS.
  • Foodservice accounts for 28.5% of in-store sales but 38.9% of in-store gross profit dollars.
  • Direct store operating expenses rose 4.2% in 2025; card fees hit a record $21.3 billion.
  • Matthews negotiated across roughly 1,400 stores at Clark Retail Enterprises and White Hen Pantry.
  • The industry runs nearly 152,000 stores handling about 160 million customer transactions daily.

U.S. convenience stores generated $817.5 billion in total sales in 2025, including $341.2 billion in in-store sales across nearly 152,000 stores, according to the National Association of Convenience Stores — and those volumes turn small negotiating wins into major money.

John Matthews, founder and president of Raleigh, N.C.-based Gray Cat Enterprises, makes the case in a new analysis for CStore Decisions. A single supplier negotiation that reduces product cost by 2% can compound across hundreds of stores and millions of units, he writes. But price is only one lever.

"Freight, payment terms, rebates, promotional funding, equipment, service levels, warranties, delivery frequency, minimum orders, exclusivity and price protection can sometimes be worth more than another percentage point off the invoice," Matthews writes.

Why the operator's background matters

Matthews speaks from roughly three decades across convenience retail, restaurants, merchandising and supplier management. At Clark Retail Enterprises and White Hen Pantry, where the companies operated about 1,400 convenience stores, he negotiated with beverage companies, foodservice suppliers, equipment manufacturers, contractors, landlords, distributors and service providers. His tenure also includes serving as president of Jimmy John's Gourmet Sandwiches and national marketing director at Little Caesar's Pizza! Pizza!

His central lesson from the c-store industry: "almost everything is negotiable." The objective was never simply to beat the other side on price, he writes, but to build an agreement that made economic sense while preserving a relationship that could keep producing value.

What does preparation actually change?

Matthews argues the best negotiators do most of their work before sitting down at the table. Retailers should know their must-haves, nice-to-haves and walk-away points. Suppliers frequently want more than an order — additional locations, better shelf positioning, greater menu penetration, preferred-supplier status or a growth commitment. Those items have trade value.

He advises negotiators to stay calm when money raises the temperature. "Sometimes silence is one of the most effective negotiating tools available," he writes. Active listening matters just as much: if a supplier cannot move further on product cost, they may instead offer better freight terms, extended payment terms, rebates, marketing dollars, training or equipment.

Which pressures raise the stakes now?

The economics of the channel have tightened. Foodservice now represents 28.5% of in-store sales but 38.9% of in-store gross profit dollars, according to figures Matthews cites. Direct store operating expenses increased 4.2% in 2025, and card fees reached a record $21.3 billion.

Those pressures, he writes, make disciplined negotiation and strong supplier relationships more important. Destroying a supplier's economics eventually creates problems for the retailer: operators need suppliers who make money, invest in their businesses, provide dependable service and want to grow with the relationship.

Matthews also counsels flexibility on timing and structure. Not every disagreement needs immediate resolution; reconvening with better information and the right people in the room often produces more. Some of his best agreements, he writes, ended differently than he originally expected because both sides challenged assumptions.

His summary after more than 30 years in the sector is direct: be prepared, stay calm, listen, know your numbers, communicate clearly and seek an agreement that creates value for both parties. The goal is not simply to resolve today's negotiation — it is to create a relationship that makes tomorrow's negotiation easier.

Source: cstoredecisions.com

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.

171 articles

Related articles

November 13, 2026C-Stores Rewire Snack Pricing as Value-Hunting Shoppers Trade Sizes
November 10, 2026C-Store Foodservice Sales Jump 28.5% as Fresh Food Sheds Its Cheap Image
September 29, 2026Instacart, Dollar General Roll Out No-Markup Delivery to 7,000 Stores
November 14, 2026Datassential Survey: 25% of Consumers Bought Meals at C-Stores
September 24, 2026Instacart, DoorDash Confront Online Grocery's Affordability Problem

« Previous articleNext article »