Published
4 min read
By Daniel Okafor

Shopper Marketing

Poor AI experiences may have cost UK retailers £8.6bn

Retailers cutting staff and training may weaken complex-product advice, even as three quarters of purchases stay in stores and poor AI experiences may have cost UK retail £8.6bn.

Complex products need expert advice – cutting staff investment puts that at risk
PhotoComplex products need expert advice – cutting staff investment puts that at riskElasticComputeFarm / pixabay

At a glance

  • A CEBR and Trustpilot study published in October last year said poor AI experiences may have cost UK retail firms as much as £8.6bn in the previous 12 months.
  • Daniel Todaro says three quarters of purchases still occur in store outside the Black Friday rush.
  • 83% of consumers still prefer to speak to a real person, according to Todaro.
  • Training budgets are being cut as in-person practical training gives way to online learning, according to Todaro.
  • Todaro recommends brand ambassadors in stores or added training for stockists selling complicated products.

By Daniel Okafor

A CEBR and Trustpilot study published in October last year estimated that poor experiences with AI may have cost UK retail firms as much as £8.6bn in the previous 12 months. Daniel Todaro, CEO at Gekko Group, cited the figure. He warned that staff cuts can weaken service at the point of sale.

Todaro says rising overheads, a growing tax burden and changing employment laws have pushed retailers to cut headcount in favour of AI and technology-enabled services. He calls that response rational for physical retailers under pressure. But he says overlooked drawbacks could return as lost sales, weaker brands and costly service failures.

Why physical retail still needs staff

Outside the Black Friday rush, three quarters of purchases still occur in store, according to Todaro. He says web traffic continues to grow. He also says this makes consistent, high-quality experiences across channels more important.

Todaro defines webrooming as browsing online before an in-store purchase. Showrooming reverses that path, with an in-store look before an online purchase. He links both behaviours to the need for support across channels.

Shoppers often want to see a product before committing, even if they ultimately buy online, Todaro says. He singles out technology, white goods and furniture. He links their importance to financial pressure on single people and families. Reviews and product information sit at shoppers’ fingertips. But shoppers sometimes want someone in the know.

Todaro warns that trial or sample products meet only part of that need. If shoppers cannot find an employee, they may abandon the purchase or feel undervalued. He says either result can damage their perception of the retailer or brand.

The expertise gap behind fewer heads

For complex products, the problem extends beyond headcount, according to Todaro. He says a shopper comparing fitness trackers faces choices by brand, model, specification and price. They may know they want a ring rather than a watch, but that still leaves model and budget questions. The discovery process can become exhausting when online information conflicts.

He describes a common store journey. The shopper tries several options and waits a long time for an employee. That employee often cannot supply expert advice or genuine user experience. Todaro says retailers and brands must convert confusion into action, especially when a costly product must suit a shopper’s lifestyle and budget.

Cutting training budgets can widen the gap, Todaro says. In-person practical training is giving way to online learning. Digital modules provide a foundation. He says surface-level courses do not inspire confidence or build staff’s ability to sell complex products and services.

Todaro lists wearables, laptops, mobile phones, white goods and small domestic appliances among products that have become harder for the average shopper to understand. He argues that in-depth knowledge now helps prevent buyers’ remorse. He rejects treating it as an optional extra.

Todaro recommends brand ambassadors in stores or extra training for staff at stockists. Their role, he says, is to answer challenging questions. They must reassure shoppers and identify the model that best balances need with budget.

Todaro argues that this service builds trust and brand equity. He treats both as vital to long-term commercial success. He says the cost of ambassadors should be weighed against weak standards, low sales, possible delisting and a resulting hit to the bottom line.

Where AI helps, and where it hurts

AI can help with one specific part of retail, according to Todaro. He says digital shelf management benefits from automated services. Accurate labels, descriptions, images and tags help shoppers discover, access and compare products. These details must work across online and offline touchpoints.

Todaro warns: “Digital shelf management is one area where automated services and AI can be incredibly valuable – but when it comes to the wider customer experience, the overreliance on technology is letting many brands and retailers down.”

Customer service remains vital, Todaro says, even as much of it moves online. Retailers use chatbots to replace human interactions and reduce overheads. Yet 83% of consumers still prefer to speak to a real person, he says. He argues that shoppers recognise chatbot exchanges. Automated service does not make them feel valued.

Todaro says frustrating automated experiences also damage the customer journey and cost businesses money. He cites the CEBR and Trustpilot estimate of up to £8.6bn in losses. Even when a chatbot handles first contact, he argues that the route to human help must remain straightforward. Empathetic, expert staff can then engage in a way that suits each shopper.

What does this change for complex-product retailers?

As AI interactions disappoint and access to in-store support shrinks, human interaction becomes a premium service, according to Todaro. He says most consumers are prepared to pay more for better customer service. That premium can appear online or face to face.

For sellers of complex, big-ticket goods, his test is direct: “Customer experience should match the price point, and failing to deliver what shoppers want and need only fosters a feeling of dissatisfaction.”

Todaro’s prescription is selective. Use AI for digital shelf management, but protect trained human advice at critical sales moments. He argues that this balance supports trust and the bottom line. It also limits the service failures behind the £8.6bn estimate.

Source: retailtimes.co.uk

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.

169 articles

Related articles

October 22, 2026Ahold Delhaize's Digital Outage Is a Customer Retention Nightmare
November 5, 2026Owned Channel Focus Slips for 2026 Holiday Season
October 29, 2026400M Customers Used Alexa for Shopping in 12 Months, Amazon Says
September 24, 2026Instacart, DoorDash Confront Online Grocery's Affordability Problem
October 1, 2026AI-Referred Shoppers Spend More as AI Traffic Set to Double

« Previous article