Published
3 min read
By Nathan Brooks

Ecommerce & Digital

Amazon Pulled a 5.8-Star Christmas Ad to Make a Riskier One

Amazon replaced 'Joy Ride,' a 5.8-star System1 performer, with the new film 'Joy Delivered.' Mark Ritson calls the move a costly bet against the retailer's own evidence.

Amazon’s New Christmas Ad Is a Bet Against Itself
PhotoAmazon’s New Christmas Ad Is a Bet Against Itselfua_Bob_Dmyt_ua / pixabay

At a glance

  • Amazon's 'Joy Ride' scored the maximum 5.8 stars from System1 in 2023 and 5.7 when re-run in 2024, placing it in under 1% of all ads that year.
  • Amazon launched 'Joy Delivered,' filmed in summer around Dunedin, New Zealand, earlier in December 2025.
  • System1's analysis of over 50,000 ads found ad scores barely decline with age; Coca-Cola's 1995 'Holidays Are Coming' still scores five stars.
  • Marketers typically review their own creative for at least 9,000 hours before release, per Ritson.
  • Average brand-building campaigns peak at two to three years into execution.

Amazon retired a Christmas ad that scored a near-perfect 5.8 stars in System1's testing and replaced it this month with a new film, "Joy Delivered," that carries more risk and more cost. Mark Ritson calls it a bet against the company itself. On the evidence, he's right.

The new ad follows a traveler named Joy, stranded at an airport on Christmas Eve with every flight cancelled by heavy snow. She carries her bag of presents home the long way: a bus, a lift from donkey farmers, a night in a boat cabin on a heaving sea, a taxi driven by a giant. At each stop she hands a stranger one of the Amazon parcels meant for her family. A new version of the Beatles' "Golden Slumbers" does the emotional work. It runs like a proper movie, and the closing hug lands.

One problem is peripheral: Amazon shot its white Christmas in and around Dunedin, New Zealand, where it's currently summer. By Christmas Day most of the country will be at the beach in shorts. Charming, if you don't think about it.

What was wrong with keeping 'Joy Ride'?

Nothing. That's the point. "Joy Ride," which first ran in 2023, shows three old ladies on a snowy hill watching kids sled. One orders seat cushions from Amazon; the box arrives; the women fly down the hill and, for a few seconds, they're girls again. No dialogue, just an instrumental of "In My Life." System1 gave it the maximum 5.8 stars. Basically perfection.

Then Amazon did something rare for a big marketer. Last year it simply ran the old ad again. It scored 5.7, placing it in the company of fewer than 1% of all ads made that year. An aging ad that barely drops a tenth of a star is, by any reasonable accounting, an asset.

The pattern holds elsewhere. Coca-Cola first ran "Holidays Are Coming" in 1995; the trucks have returned every Christmas since, and System1 says the ad always scores five stars in testing. When System1 analyzed more than 50,000 ads, it found scores barely move as ads age — and some of the best actually improve as audiences get to know them. Ads don't wear out, at least not for consumers.

Why do marketers keep replacing winners?

Because the people approving the budgets are not the people watching the ads. Ritson's verdict is blunt: advertising decisions are made by marketers who like new, shiny things. Jo Shoesmith, Amazon's global chief brand officer, told ADWEEK that people want nostalgia but also "something they haven't seen before." Ritson calls that a complete contradiction.

The math compounds the error. The average brand-building campaign reaches maximum impact two to three years into execution, and seasonal work can run for decades, as Coke has proved. Yet marketers typically review their own creative for at least 9,000 hours before release — they're sick of it before most of the target market has noticed it. The same pattern, Ritson notes, applies to slogans, logos and distinctive brand assets.

There is a middle path: Coca-Cola's approach of running the heritage ad annually alongside a weaker new execution. Ritson doesn't rate it. Why create a bat to beat yourself with, he asks, when the outstanding, already-made, already-free, already-proven ad can simply be withdrawn and replaced with something less good?

The broader lesson lands hardest on the trade. Marketers routinely ask for more CEO support, more budget, more boardroom seats. What they mostly need, Ritson argues, is patience — good campaigns take years, not months. Amazon knew that last Christmas, when it re-ran "Joy Ride" to near-top marks. It has already forgotten.

Editor's note: Brave Bison, which acquired Mark Ritson's MiniMBA in 2025, owns about 28% of System1 and sought to acquire the rest this year.

Source: adweek.com

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.

198 articles

Related articles

November 13, 2026Waitrose's Six-Minute Christmas Film Drew 2.5 Million ITV Viewers
November 19, 2026Amazon Drafts Arnold Schwarzenegger as Santa for Holiday Push
October 19, 2026Anthropologie's Holiday Push Lands Oct. 19, With DoorDash in Tow
November 11, 2026Target and Walmart Bet on Storytelling, Not Price, This Holiday
October 23, 2026Macy's Reimagines Santaland and Expands Holiday Square at Herald Square

« Previous articleNext article »