- Section
- Grocery & CPG
- Published
- 4 min read
- By Nathan Brooks
Grocery & CPG
Fareway's 88-Year Balance: Half Heritage, Half Future
The 88-year-old Iowa grocer splits leadership 50-50 between heritage and future, adding 100,000 square feet of cold storage while shrinking store footprints for rural towns.

At a glance
- Fareway Stores Inc. is 88 years old, family-owned, based in Johnston, Iowa, and operates in seven states with more than 14,000 employees.
- CEO Reynolds Cramer splits his focus 50 percent heritage and 50 percent future strategy.
- Fareway is expanding its refrigerated distribution building from about 250,000 to 350,000 square feet.
- Focus-group feedback prompted a companywide produce retrofit with new shelving and organic offerings.
- Fareway reaches its 100th anniversary in about 12 years; Cramer expects to be retired by then.
Fareway Stores Inc., an 88-year-old family-owned grocer operating in seven states with more than 14,000 employees, splits its leadership focus exactly in half: 50 percent heritage, 50 percent future. That's how CEO Reynolds Cramer, who leads the Johnston, Iowa-based company, describes his job — especially over the last 15 years.
"The whole idea is saying that we're not 100 percent stuck in the past because I feel like if we had been, we wouldn't be where we are today," Cramer said. The Shelby Report of the Midwest named Fareway its 2026 Retailer of the Year.
What changed a company that 'knew who it was'?
For roughly 80 years, Fareway built stores one way and dressed employees in white shirts and black ties — a uniform Cramer wore himself for more than three decades. The rethink started with a suggestion from Scott Beckwith, his cousin who retired as chief administrative officer: run a focus group.
Cramer's first reaction was skepticism. "At first, my thought – and I think [that of] others – was why do we need a focus group? We know who we are. We know what we're doing," he said.
Fareway ran two sessions, one in a small town and one in a larger city. Cramer and about seven colleagues watched from behind a one-way mirror as shoppers reported on Fareway and its competitors. Praise for the meat counter felt familiar. Then came the produce verdict.
"I bought some produce, and I went to Fareway and bought produce, and their produce was terrible," one participant said. Cramer called it a defining moment: "Just because we think we're the best doesn't really matter. The customer has to think we're the best."
Months later, Cramer took a team to a produce trade show in New Orleans. Fareway retrofitted every produce section in the company with new shelving and added organic offerings. "Things just took off in our produce department," he said. The same test-and-feedback process — test stores, employee and customer input, changes rolled out "once we feel like it's 99 percent there" — reshaped uniforms, storefronts and other longstanding practices.
How does Cramer run the business day to day?
He skips formal multiyear strategic plans. Instead: a five-year destination, narrowed to an annual list of 10 priorities. "Every year, when you get to the end of the year, you go to that list, and you're proud of the fact that you checked four of those off," he said. His warning to managers: don't get stuck on priority No. 8. It matters. It's still No. 8.
Decision volume isn't the hard part, he said. "I can make 20 decisions every hour. I have no problem with that. What I have to do, though, is I have to make sure that the team is a part of those."
Where is the capital going?
Fareway is adding about 100,000 square feet to the roughly 250,000-square-foot refrigerated building at its distribution center — a 40 percent expansion that will bring it to 350,000 square feet, adding zero-degree space and minus-20-degree rooms for ice cream. Steel is already up. "When we get done with this expansion, we will be in an even better position to be efficient and also have more holding power," Cramer said. The company has also updated its ASRS towers with new technology to prepare for more automation and robotics.
On investment, Cramer sticks to what Fareway knows. "We try not to be everything to everyone, and we invest in partners that perhaps are better at doing things than we would be," he said, citing leased pharmacy space. Rather than chase oversaturated markets, Fareway targets growing communities and rural towns with a smaller footprint and sometimes lower-cost building materials.
What does the store mean to a town?
Cramer calls each Fareway store a "second mayor, the second city council." In Norwalk, Iowa, where he lives, the company ran a roundup campaign after an apartment building burned down — one displaced resident worked in a Fareway meat department — and matched what customers raised. The same day he attended the Stars and Strikes Charity Classic, a softball event with firefighters, police and EMTs organized by Fareway AVP of Marketing Taylor Blanchard with Anheuser-Busch and Doll Distributing of Des Moines, played on a field cut from a cornfield on the Moeckly family farm north of Polk City. Proceeds support families in crisis, including mortgage payoffs through Folds of Honor Iowa, a group Cramer said is new to the state.
On legacy, Cramer is blunt. Asked at a management meeting of more than 300 who remembered Bill Beckwith and Bob Cramer — the uncle and father who led the company over 20 years ago — about 15 hands went up. "I'm not doing this for legacy," he said. "What I'm doing it for is so next generations can have the same opportunity and the benefit that I received."
Fareway hits its 100th anniversary in about 12 years. Cramer expects to be retired by then, attending as "one spoke on the wheel" — with the people in place, he said, to keep raising the bar.
Source: theshelbyreport.com
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.
198 articles
Related articles
| November 4, 2026 | Eight top grocery executive changes announced in October |
| September 28, 2026 | Groceryshop: AI Dominated the Conversation |
| November 17, 2026 | Earth Fare Names Ben Burton President as Growth Push Continues |
| October 27, 2026 | Wakefern's Sales Growth Slows to 2%, Its Weakest Since 2021 |
| October 15, 2026 | Publix Promotes Laurie Douglas to Chief Information and Digital Officer |