Published
4 min read
By Nathan Brooks

Retail & Distribution

Quality beats price 2-4 to 1 as real retail spend sits 10% below 2022

OC&C's 2026 Retail Proposition Index finds quality now counts 2-4 times more than low price, real spend per shopper sits 10% below 2022, and services spending grew 13.6%.

Retailers risk losing shoppers by competing on price as quality becomes the bigger driver of value
PhotoRetailers risk losing shoppers by competing on price as quality becomes the bigger driver of valueStockSnap / pixabay

At a glance

  • Real retail spend per shopper is about 10% below 2022 levels, with retailer margins stabilised but depressed.
  • Quality is now 2 to 4 times more important than low price across all categories and buyer demographics.
  • Purchasing priorities have shifted 3 percentage points from low price towards quality since 2024.
  • Under-35s moved 1.5 to 2 percentage points of spend to quality-led retailers in the past year, spending more per head there.
  • Services and experiences spending grew 13.6% between 2022 and 2025 versus 9.3% for physical goods; OC&C puts the opportunity at £300bn.

Real retail spend per shopper sits about 10% below its 2022 level, and the 2026 Retail Proposition Index from OC&C Strategy Consultants finds quality now counts two to four times more than low price across every category and buyer demographic it measures.

That is the headline number for anyone running a price-led proposition. Three percentage points of purchasing priority have swung from low price towards quality since 2024, and the report's conclusion is blunt: discounts and price-led propositions alone may no longer be enough to close the gap on real spend and accelerate growth.

Retailer margins have stabilised. They have not recovered. And shoppers aged 16 to 35 are purchasing less frequently than their older counterparts, which is why OC&C frames the fix as value per transaction rather than volume.

Who is moving the money

Olivia May, Retail Partner at OC&C Strategy Consultants, is direct about which cohort is doing the moving. "Generation Z and younger Millennials are driving this shift," she said. "Our data reveals that under 35s have shifted 1.5-2 percentage points of their spend towards quality-led retailers in the last year, and they are spending more per head at quality-led retailers than at price-led retailers."

The report's key figures:

  • Real retail spend per shopper: roughly 10% below 2022 levels
  • Quality's weight versus price: 2 to 4 times more important, across all categories and demographics
  • Shift in purchasing priorities from low price to quality: 3 percentage points since 2024
  • Under-35 spend moving to quality-led retailers: 1.5 to 2 percentage points in the past year
  • Growth in services and experiences spending: 13.6% between 2022 and 2025, against 9.3% for physical goods
  • Value OC&C flags in consumer services and experiences: £300bn

May sets out the mechanism: "When consumers are purchasing less frequently but spending more during each purchase, retailers need to focus on increasing the value of each transaction by improving product quality and service in order to win back spend and drive growth. Those that can demonstrate why their products are worth investing in will be better positioned to compete for consumer spending."

Where the money is actually growing

Physical goods still fill the shelves, but spending on services and experiences has grown about 1.5 times faster since 2022 and has been much less volatile, even as consumer spending failed to keep pace with inflation.

Cumulative growth in services and experiences reached 13.6% between 2022 and 2025, against 9.3% for physical goods. OC&C puts the opening for retailers at £300bn in consumer services and experiences, which suggests expanding beyond traditional product offerings gives a second route to growth.

May named the retailers already walking that road. "Lush, Space NK and John Lewis are great examples of retailers that are successfully expanding beyond physical goods and creating memorable customer experiences in store," she said. "As a result, they all appear in the top 10 for our 'customer service' ranking across all categories, while Lush and Space NK also rank as the top 2 brands that are 'fun to shop' across all categories."

Worth reading that ranking closely. All three make the customer service top 10. Only two of them, Lush and Space NK, take the top two 'fun to shop' slots across all categories.

What does this change for price-led retailers?

Do the arithmetic. If a shopper visits less often and spends more per trip, a markdown has to work harder per basket, and a price cannot close a quality gap that OC&C now measures at two to four times the weight of price.

May also offered a caution for anyone waiting for a rebound. "For the last 16 years our annual study of shopping behaviour has followed consumers on a real rollercoaster," she said. "Using proprietary Barclays Spend Insights Data this year, we're able to see that while retail is an unforgiving environment, there is clear space for retailers to not just survive, but thrive."

That last word is the operative one. The 2026 index puts under-35 spend growth at quality-led retailers, and the retailers catching them are selling an experience rather than a discount. Price-led retailers can win a single visit. Winning the second is harder.

Source: retailtimes.co.uk

Share this article:

More from Nathan Brooks

Nathan Brooks

Show full bio

Market editor covering companies, deals and strategy in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.

198 articles

Related articles

September 22, 202693% of Americans Have Adopted At Least One Cost-Saving Measure
September 24, 2026Instacart, DoorDash Confront Online Grocery's Affordability Problem
September 25, 2026Costco Beats Aldi in Grocery Value Perception, YouGov Finds
September 22, 202697% of Americans Worry About Gas Prices — and It's Reshaping C-Store Trips
November 19, 2026Poor AI experiences may have cost UK retailers £8.6bn

« Previous articleNext article »