Published
4 min read
By Daniel Okafor

Shopper Marketing

Skims' $148 Advent Calendar Proves Disclosure No Longer Protects Premium Brands

Skims listed every door of its $148 advent calendar online. Buyers revolted anyway. Negative posts outnumbered positive ones eight to one, per Fortune-cited data.

Skims’ advent calendar debacle shows ‘value’ is more important than ever
PhotoSkims’ advent calendar debacle shows ‘value’ is more important than everMyriams-Fotos / pixabay

At a glance

  • Skims' $148 advent calendar went on sale October 29, 2026, listed all contents online, and still sold out.
  • Starlight Analytics found negative posts about Skims outnumbered positive ones about 8-to-1 between November 2-11.
  • Kayla Ryan's unboxing video drew 25.2 million views; another drew 77.6 million.
  • Skims offered every buyer a full refund or store credit and pulled the calendar from sale.
  • Blackhawk Network's 2026 research found nearly 60 percent of shoppers spend beyond a gift card's balance.

Negative posts about Skims outnumbered positive ones roughly eight to one between November 2 and 11, after its $148 advent calendar turned out to contain 24 accessories worth roughly $6 each — and the contents were listed on the website the whole time. Starlight Analytics, tracking US social posts for Fortune, found negative sentiment hit 13 percent of mentions on November 6 and 76 percent on November 11, based on a partial day.

The calendar went on sale October 29 as part of Skims' 2026 Holiday Shop, priced at $148 in the US. It sold out. Then the unboxings started, and the verdict came from people who never bought one.

What did buyers actually find inside?

Creator Kayla Ryan finished her unboxing with three hair ties, six scrunchies, six bobby pins, two hair clips, two thin headbands, four keychains and a squishy toy. Twenty-four pieces at roughly $6 each, inside a $148 box. Her video drew 25.2 million views. A creator posting as @wetsloppyswollen drew 77.6 million.

"I can get these at Dollar Tree," Ryan told viewers.

The comparisons did more damage than the product itself. Baller Alert reported TikTok users calling the contents "Temu junk." YPulse said Gen Z users dubbed it the "Fyre Festival of Advent Calendars." For a brand that prices itself above mass-market basics, the Temu comparison wounds the positioning, not just one SKU.

Why didn't disclosure save the brand?

That's the practical question for anyone selling at a premium. Skims didn't deceive anyone — the website listed every door's contents. But disclosure answers "What is inside?" Buyers were asking a different question: "Is this worth it?" The listing couldn't tell them how it would feel to open a door that cost about $12 and find three hair elastics.

The format amplified the damage. An advent calendar sells anticipation; each door promises the next one might be better. When contents disappoint, that disappointment arrives 12 times and builds to a finale. One TikToker said the last door would have to be "made of gold" to justify the price. Behind it was a keychain.

The judges, crucially, were mostly spectators. Of the 65 million people who watched the viral video, most will never hold the product. They still set its price in public.

How did Skims respond?

A spokesperson told Page Six the company was "aware of the feedback some customers have shared about the Skims Advent Calendar, and we've listened carefully." Skims contacted every buyer with a choice: a full refund with return, or Skims credit to keep the calendar. The calendar came off sale.

The mechanics were sound. The language wasn't. "We've listened carefully" acknowledges feedback without saying what went wrong — and it landed while commenters compared the product to dust under the sofa.

Then founding partner and chief product officer Emma Grede, asked by a TMZ reporter what she'd say to "the haters," replied she didn't worry about them. The clip drew 1.3 million TikTok views, with comments pointing out the "haters" were customers.

Some observers read the whole episode as deliberate. Jessica Tillery, senior vice president of brand communications at Allison Worldwide, wrote on LinkedIn she'd "bet money it was intentional," Fortune reported. Blackhawk Network's 2026 research, also cited by Fortune, found nearly 60 percent of shoppers spend beyond a gift card's balance — a plausible path from refunds to store credit to full-price sales.

The likelier explanation is more ordinary, and more useful: Skims stretched its name into a category where it had nothing to sell but the name. Its own Panty Advent Calendar contains what customers come to Skims for. The accessories calendar asked the logo to do all the work.

What does this change for value marketing?

Disclosure is now the minimum, not the defense. Before launch, brands should have someone with no stake in the product open it on camera and ask whether each door survives the comments. The test matters most for "low-risk" items — gift sets, calendars, add-ons, limited drops — because they're the most likely to be filmed and the least likely to contain what the brand is known for.

Skims will survive a box of hair ties; its sales reportedly passed $1 billion last year. Trust is harder to restore. Shoppers will open the next Skims box remembering this one.

Source: insideretail.asia

Share this article:

More from Daniel Okafor

Daniel Okafor

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in trade marketing, shopper marketing, trade promotions, category management at Target Marketing.

169 articles

Related articles

November 16, 2026Adult Collectors Drive 20% Surge in U.S. Toy Sales
September 22, 2026Label Clips Jumped 606% on Shopify in August
October 30, 2026Hershey sees Halloween risk as candy sales slip 6.7%
October 26, 2026CVS expands into Pokémon, collectibles and seasonal drops
September 23, 2026Halloween Shopping Starts Earlier and Skews Cheaper in 2025

« Previous articleNext article »